Review cross-posted on our sister site, Caterpickles.
The Hidden Alphabet
By Laura Vaccaro Seeger
Roaring Brook Press, 2003
Age Range: 4-8
Laura Seeger’s The Hidden Alphabet is a work of art posing as an alphabet book. Black lift-up flaps frame stunningly simple images of birds, mice, eggs, even quotation marks–setting these rather humble, everyday objects up as works of art in their own right. Lift the flaps and the objects reveal themselves to be a notch in a K, the hole in an R, or the curve of an S.
There is a lot of art in this book, but very little text
The book’s only text is the name of the objects in the black frame. The result is a blend of short, unimposing text and familiar images that encourages my daughter to try sounding out the words on her own.
What The Four-Year-Old thinks
If you ask my daughter, she’ll tell you she doesn’t like this book because there is too much black on the cover. And in fact, she will never pick this book up off the shelf for herself (I have about 6 months of anecdotal data to prove this).
At the same time, when we read this book this week, she was fully engaged, lifting the flaps, sounding out words, and critiquing the artist’s rendition of the various letters.
She doesn’t like the cover, but she loves the contents
Even if this book left my daughter completely cold, I would still pull it out to read with her on occasion because the illustrations are that good. At one point, my daughter turned the page and said, “Wow.”
I say “wow” on nearly every page.
This book is a visual feast.
So why didn’t I give it a 5? The cover. We have an early edition of the book that uses a solid black sheet with boxes stamped out of it through which the letters of the title appear. Although my adult self understands completely and fully endorses the genius of this book’s cover, the nearly unrelenting black keeps my daughter from ever picking up this book on her own.
And that’s a problem.
Looks like other people may have had a problem with the cover too
Based on the Amazon listing, it looks like they’ve changed the cover for the more recent editions. Perhaps my daughter isn’t the only child who doesn’t want to read a book draped in all that black.